900+ trademarks monitored
Back to Blog

Etsy Approved My Appeal Twice. Then Flagged It Again.

by Viktors Telle 7 min read

Reinstated. Flagged again. Reinstated. Flagged again.

Same listing. Same seller. Three times in about a week and a half, based on a thread I came across in r/EtsySellers a few days ago. Each time, a human reviewer looked at the case and said yes, this is real, put it back. And each time, within a day of going back up, the automated system took it right back down.

I want to sit with that for a second, because it's a different problem than the one everyone already knows about.

What actually happened

The seller makes handmade "Backrooms" infinity mirror boxes. If you don't know what that is, don't worry about it, it's an internet horror aesthetic thing, and worth saying up front: it's not owned by anyone. One commenter on the thread asked if this was a trademark issue and got corrected fast. The Backrooms is a community-built idea, dozens of artists have made their own versions, nobody holds it. So that part's a dead end.

The listing did well. Well enough that copies started showing up on Amazon and, eventually, on Etsy itself, from other shops. And that's when things got weird for the original maker.

Etsy pulled the listing under Creativity Standards, the "this doesn't look handmade to us" bucket, not a copyright or trademark claim. The seller appealed with design files, prototypes, and process video. Approved. Reinstated. A day later, gone again. They appealed a second time. Approved again. Reinstated again. This time they went further and stripped out most of the listing photos that could be matched to the Amazon knockoffs, keeping just one new shot. Removed a third time anyway, the day after it came back.

At that point they tried something different: a brand new listing, new photos, nothing carried over from the flagged one. Down within two hours.

As of when I read the thread, it was still unresolved. Etsy support had escalated the case to what they described as a dedicated team, and the seller was sitting there asking the rest of the sub whether to keep fighting the same listing or just start over again. Nobody had a clean answer, because there isn't one yet.

This isn't the fake-DMCA story

If you've read what I've written before about weaponized takedowns, this is going to sound familiar. But it isn't the same animal, and the difference matters.

A fake DMCA has a person behind it. Someone files a bogus copyright claim, you can eventually identify them, counter-notice them, sometimes even take them to the Copyright Claims Board. There's an actual villain in that story. I wrote up that whole process here if that's what you're dealing with.

This is not that. Nobody filed anything against the Backrooms seller. There's no rights holder, no claim to counter, no opposing party to identify. It's Etsy's own systems deciding, on their own, that a thing which is genuinely handmade doesn't look handmade enough, over and over, even after a person at Etsy already looked at the evidence and said otherwise.

I went deep on how those detection systems actually work in an earlier piece - the text models, the image models, the cross-platform matching against AliExpress and Temu, the "champion vs challenger" way Etsy tests new ML models against old ones. One thing I noted there: independent analysis of Etsy's own transparency numbers suggests something like 80% of automated flags might not hold up on review. That's the backdrop. This story is what it looks like when you're standing inside that 80%, and winning your appeal doesn't actually get you out of it.

The part nobody explains: why does winning not stick

Here's my best read on the mechanics, and I'll say up front this is inference, because Etsy doesn't publish this level of detail.

A human reviewer overturning one flag on one listing doesn't appear to retrain or suppress whatever pattern triggered the original flag. It just overrides that one instance. The listing goes back up, but the underlying signal that got it pulled in the first place, probably some combination of "this image also exists elsewhere" and "this pattern resembles mass production," is still sitting there. Nothing about the human's decision tells the model not to score it that way again next time it runs.

So the review and the detection aren't really talking to each other. One is a one-time human judgment call. The other is a standing score that gets recalculated on its own schedule, or possibly re-triggered every time a competing image shows up somewhere new. If a copy is still circulating on Amazon while the original sits on Etsy, both showing the "same" product to a matching system, there's no guarantee the algorithm favors the one that was actually first. Sellers in the comments floated the same theory: the account with more sales volume and more "activity" elsewhere reads as more legitimate to the system than the smaller original maker, regardless of who made the thing.

That's not a policy. It's just how a scoring system behaves when nobody's told it to remember what a person already decided.

The other version of this: when you're not even the product

A second thread, about a month older, shows a related but distinct failure mode. A different seller, over two years on Etsy, more than 6,000 sales, over a thousand five-star reviews, star seller since their second month, so not a new or sketchy account by any measure, had a listing pulled for Creativity Standards too. Their theory: they sell accessories designed to work with a mass-produced product, and one of their listing photos showed the accessory attached to that product so buyers could see the fit. They think an automated system read that photo and concluded they were reselling the mass-produced item itself, rather than a handmade accessory for it.

They appealed with photos and video. It worked, first try, and they said as much when they updated their post: the appeal was resolved in their favor, so at least for now a human is still actually reading these.

Put the two threads next to each other and you get the honest, unsatisfying picture: sometimes one appeal fixes it clean. Sometimes it doesn't, and nothing about the two situations tells you in advance which one you're going to get.

What to actually do with this

A few things, none of them a guarantee, because there isn't one right now.

Keep your process evidence ready before you need it, not after. Design files with edit history, prototype photos, screen recordings of you actually making the thing. This is the same evidence locker advice I've given for fake takedowns, and it applies here too, just aimed at a different opponent.

Be explicit in your listing description about what the thing is and who made it. One commenter on the mirror-box thread mentioned doing exactly this after their own Creativity Standards removal, spelling out plainly that the product was their own design, made by them, and said they think it helped. No proof it's a fix, but it's free and it takes two sentences.

If you're selling an accessory or add-on for a mass-produced product, think hard about whether your photos could be read as claiming you sell the product itself. A demo shot showing fit or compatibility is useful for buyers and, apparently, risky for the algorithm.

And if the same listing keeps getting re-flagged after repeated approved appeals, know that starting fresh with a new listing isn't a guaranteed fix either. It worked for at least one seller I've seen mention it. It did not work, at least not yet, for the mirror-box seller, whose brand new listing lasted two hours.

Why does Etsy flag a genuinely handmade listing for mass production?

Usually because Etsy's image-matching systems found the same or similar images somewhere else, often a marketplace like Amazon or AliExpress, and can't reliably tell whether your listing is the original or the copy. Higher-volume or higher-activity accounts appear to get the benefit of the doubt more often, which can work against a smaller original maker whose design got copied onto a bigger operation elsewhere.

Does winning an appeal stop Etsy from flagging the same listing again?

Not necessarily. A human reviewer overturning a flag appears to override that one decision without retraining the underlying automated system, so the same listing can get re-scored and re-flagged later, sometimes within a day, even with no new complaint and no new evidence against it.


Resources

Related reading:

Etsy's own pages:

If Creativity Standards is a moving target for your shop, run a free scan of your listings before Etsy's systems find something to flag. No signup required.

Scan a listing free

Paste your title and description and get a plain-English compliance report before Etsy flags it. No signup, 3 free a day.

Run a free scan

Related Articles