The Hot Girls Read Trademark Backfired in Days
I was half-watching my phone the other night when this whole thing crossed my feed. A creator posting that she had trademarked a phrase. Not a logo, not a brand name. A phrase. One I'd seen on hundreds of little book-themed shops. Bookmarks, tote bags, sweatshirts, the works.
"Hot Girls Read."
And then the part that made me sit up. She was telling other sellers, out loud, that if they had that phrase on anything they were selling, they needed to take it down. People who had been making bookmarks with those three words for years were suddenly being told the phrase belonged to someone else now.
That one got under my skin. Because I've been the small seller on the wrong end of a "this is mine now" message before, and it is a horrible feeling. You don't know if you're about to lose your shop. You don't know if you need a lawyer. You just know somebody with more confidence than you is telling you to delete your work.
So I went and read everything I could find on it. And honestly? The way it ended up is one of the better trademark stories I've seen in a while.
So here's what actually happened
The creator is Allie Mitrovich, who runs a shop called Allie Rose Co. She'd been selling "Hot Girls Read" bookmarks since 2023, and she filed a trademark application on the phrase back in August 2024. Earlier this month, around June 3rd, she announced she'd secured it and asked other shops to stop selling anything with the phrase on it.
To be clear about one thing, because it matters: she didn't, by her own account, fire off cease-and-desist letters or run to Etsy to get listings pulled. She later said she never did any of that. It was a public post telling people to delist. But when you're a tiny shop and someone waves the word "trademark" at you, the difference between a legal threat and a strongly worded post doesn't really register. It just feels like a threat.
BookTok did not take it well. At all.
People pointed out the obvious problem, which is that "hot girls read" wasn't something she came up with. It's a phrase that had been floating around reading communities for ages. The whole "hot girl" thing traces back way further than any of this, through early-2000s Lil Wayne lyrics and then the 2019 "Hot Girl Summer" wave with Megan Thee Stallion. Loads of people had been slapping "hot girls read" on bookish merch long before any paperwork got filed.
So the community pushed back hard. A fantasy author even started a GoFundMe, "Stand with Small Book Creators Against Trademark Abuse," to pay for a legal challenge at the trademark office. The plan was to gather proof that other people were using the phrase first and get the whole thing cancelled.
And then, within days, it was over. Allie posted an apology video. The line that stuck with me was "I'm so sorry to every small business that I harmed." She filed to give the trademark back. By around June 8th or 9th, the status on the USPTO record had flipped to "expressly abandoned." Gone. The mark she'd announced with a lot of confidence at the start of the month was voluntarily surrendered before the month was half over.
I'll say this for her. Plenty of people dig in when they're wrong. She didn't. She walked it back and said sorry in plain words, which is more than a lot of bigger companies manage.
Wait, can you even trademark something like that?
This is the bit I actually care about. The gossip part gets forgotten by next week. This part doesn't.
You can file a trademark application for almost anything. Filing is just paperwork and a fee. The trademark office isn't sitting there going "ah, but lots of people already say this," at least not in any deep way at first. So someone filing on a common phrase and even getting it through to registration does not mean they truly own it in the way they think they do.
A trademark is supposed to protect something that identifies your specific brand. Not a saying that thousands of people already use to mean a general idea. And when a phrase is already everywhere, it's on shaky ground before you even start.
The big one is prior use. If other sellers were already putting "hot girls read" on their shops before she filed, the claim to own it gets weak fast. US trademark rights lean hard on who was actually using the mark in commerce. Not who got to the paperwork first.
Genericness is the other thing that sinks these. Once a phrase is basically just what everybody says, you can't really wall it off as your own. That's the whole Hot Girl Walk fight, still dragging on. That trademark got registered, the owner enforced it aggressively, and then Fashion Nova turned around and argued the mark was secured by fraud and that the phrase had gone generic from all the TikTok use. I wrote about that mess and a pile of other "wait, that's trademarked?" words in this post if you want to go down that rabbit hole.
Point is, a registration on a phrase everybody already says is a lot shakier than it looks.
This keeps happening, by the way
If you've been selling on Etsy for a while, none of this is new. People try to lock down common phrases constantly.
"Boy Mom" is the one that catches the most sellers off guard. "BOYMOM" with no space is trademarked by an LLC that's known in seller circles for going after people hard. The mark covers clothing, drinkware, candles, a bunch of stuff. "Girl Mom," "Dog Mom," "Girl Dad," "Boy Dad" have all had filings floating around too. Phrases you'd swear nobody could own, and yet.
And Hot Girl Walk, like I mentioned, has turned into a years-long legal slugfest with federal lawsuits and counterclaims, all over a phrase that started as a TikTok trend.
The pattern is always the same. Somebody builds a small thing around a popular phrase, watches it take off, and decides the phrase itself is the asset worth fencing in. A few of them actually get the registration through. Some go after people with it. And once in a while the whole thing detonates in public the way Hot Girls Read just did. If you want the bigger picture on how trademark trouble actually gets your listings flagged, my full guide to avoiding trademark violations walks through it, and there's a database of 900+ trademarked brands by niche if you want to check your own categories.
OK but what do you do if someone comes at your listings
Say it's you. You're selling something with a common phrase on it and one day a message lands telling you to take it all down because it's trademarked now. Here's what I'd do before doing anything rash.
First thing, and I mean it: don't nuke your listings in a panic. A post yelling into the void, or even a DM, is not a legal order. It's just someone telling you what they want. Different thing entirely from an actual Etsy takedown.
Then go check whether the mark is even real. Pull up the USPTO, search the phrase, look at the status. There's a big gap between a pending application and a live registered mark, and a bigger one between "registered" and "would actually hold up if challenged." Half of these scary claims are an application sitting in a queue, nothing more.
Who was using it first? That's your strongest card. If you can show you were selling that phrase before they filed, that prior use counts for a lot. Screenshot your old listings, dated receipts, anything that nails down your timeline, and stash it somewhere safe.
And yeah, you can actually fight back. Anyone can ask the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board to cancel a mark that never should have been granted. That's exactly what the GoFundMe in this saga was paying for. There's also a Facebook group called Trademark Watchdogs where sellers chip in together to go after the worst ones, since doing it solo gets pricey fast.
Now, if what you get is not a public post but an actual takedown on Etsy or a DMCA notice, that's a different animal with its own process. I covered the situation where a competitor weaponizes a fake takedown against you here, and that's worth reading if you ever find your listing yanked overnight.
How to check a phrase before you build anything on it
Honestly the easiest move is to just check before you build anything around a phrase. Takes two minutes. Saves you a genuinely bad week.
- USPTO Trademark Search for US marks. Type the phrase, look for anything marked "LIVE," and read what goods it actually covers. A mark for "bookmarks" doesn't necessarily cover, say, candles.
- EUIPO eSearch plus if you sell into Europe.
- WIPO Global Brand Database for a wider international look.
A phrase showing up in a search doesn't automatically mean hands off forever. But it tells you who's claiming what, and it lets you make a real decision instead of a scared one.
Can you trademark a common phrase?
You can file an application on almost any phrase, and sometimes it even registers. But a phrase that lots of people already use is weak. Prior use by other sellers and genericness can both knock the mark down, and getting a registration doesn't mean it would survive a real legal challenge. The Hot Girls Read application was surrendered within days once the community pushed back.
What happened with the Hot Girls Read trademark?
Allie Mitrovich of Allie Rose Co. announced in early June 2026 that she'd trademarked "Hot Girls Read" and asked other sellers to stop using it. After heavy backlash from the book community, including a GoFundMe to fund a legal challenge, she apologized and surrendered the trademark. By around June 8th to 9th, 2026, the USPTO record showed the mark as expressly abandoned.
What should I do if someone says I'm infringing their phrase on Etsy?
First, check whether their mark is actually a live registration or just a pending application by searching the USPTO. Don't assume a public demand is a legal order. If you were using the phrase before they filed, document that prior use with dated screenshots. You can challenge a questionable mark at the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board. And if you get a real Etsy takedown rather than just a message, follow Etsy's counter-notice process rather than deleting and hoping.
Resources
Check a phrase yourself:
Challenge a bad mark:
Further reading:
- Etsy Intellectual Property Policy
- A content creator tried to trademark Hot Girls Read (Literary Hub)
- Hot Girls Read trademark owner surrenders registration (Gerben IP)
Not sure if a phrase or word in your listings is someone else's trademark? Create a free account and run your shop through Listing Compliance Shield to catch potential trademark and policy issues before they catch you.
Related Articles
World Cup Merch on Etsy: What's Safe, What's Not
FIFA owns way more than the words World Cup - the logo, the mascots, the trophy, even WC26. What you can and can't put on Etsy soccer merch in 2026.
Mother's Day Trademark Traps Etsy Sellers Miss
The trademarked phrases, brand names, and fonts hiding in your Mother's Day listings. Real registration numbers and what to use instead.
900+ Trademarked Brands That Get Etsy Sellers Suspended
Our database of 900+ trademarked brands across 20+ seller categories. Find your niche and see every trademark that could get your Etsy shop flagged.